Building loyalty from zero for 16,000 pizzerias · Barbara Perkowski
BP
← All workCase study · 6 min read
Case study · 0→1 · Consumer loyaltySlice · Rewards · 2020–21

Building loyaltyfrom zero for16,000 pizzerias

No product, no pattern, no agreed model. I set the design vision for Slice Rewards, took it from a blank page to launch, and turned a flat start into a measured lift in repeat purchases.

One rule anyone can repeat, and a pizza that fills as you order.

5 chapters · 6 min read
CompanySlice · iOS and Android
My roleSenior Product Designer, design lead 0→1 · design vision, touchpoints, motion, research and testing; co-wrote the roadmap with the PM
TeamSr PM, Eng Lead + 7 engineers, with Marketing and Data
TimelineJun 2020 – Q3 2021 · MVP March 2021
{{ proto }}
2021 release

The case at a glance

01Problem

Independent pizzerias were losing regulars to chains with loyalty apps.

02Challenge

A network-wide program for 16,000 shops that still feels simple.

03What I did

Took it from a blank page to one rule and shipped it. When launch came in flat, I found why and fixed it in the flow.

04What changed

Repeat purchases up 4–9% by Q2, statistically significant.

Decision log

Five bets. One I got wrong.

Open any bet for what I believed and the signal that proved it right or wrong.

  1. 01 · Jun 2020— Kept Design for the 1.2M developing users Days between orders fell from 30 to 10.
    BeliefIf we reward people already close to a habit, days between orders drop.
    SignalPushback: too narrow to move the business. New users were the obvious target.
    Chapter 1 →
  2. 02 · 2020— Kept One rule: 8 orders = a free pizza Leadership chose it; testers explained it back in one line.
    BeliefIf anyone can repeat the rule in one line, opt-in rises.
    SignalPushback: Marketing wanted tiers and a catalog. I mocked five models in the real Home screen, side by side.
    Chapter 1 →
  3. 03 · Late 2020— Learned Start everyone at 1 of 8 51% never got past the welcome point.
    BeliefIf no one starts at zero, more people place a second order.
    SignalThe stall became the clearest signal for the pivot below.
    Chapter 2 →
  4. 04 · Q1 2021— Pivoted
    I cut celebrations to ship on time. Retention stayed flat.So I went into the data and moved the program into the order flow: points at checkout, celebrations back, a cart that confirms the point.
    Flat14-day retention after launch
    51%stuck at the welcome point
    17–19%ever opened the Rewards tab
    +4–9%repeat purchases after the pivot
    Chapter 3 →
  5. 05 · Q2 2021— Kept Never break the promise at redemption Still live in 2026, marketed as America’s biggest pizza rewards program.
    BeliefIf every redemption just works, people order again after the free pizza.
    SignalTesting surfaced three breaks: orders over $25, refunds and expiring rewards.
    Chapter 4 →
Where it started

Regulars were leaving

Customers were ordering from Domino’s, Papa John’s and Pizza Hut, which rewarded them for ordering again. Independent shops had nothing, and retention of Slice’s power users had dropped 5%.

Slice decided to fund the reward itself, on a fixed launch date before the investor pitch. In interviews, people who’d tried chain programs named three reasons they quit: confusing rules, slow progress, and not knowing when they had a reward. Each became a constraint: one rule, a head start, and telling people the moment they earn.

What the research found
9 of 19quit loyalty apps because they didn’t know when they had a reward.
90%of shop owners wanted a loyalty program.
40%wouldn’t fund a pizza earned at other shops.
A delivery driver checks the ticket on a fresh hot pizza box on a city sidewalk
A customer in a yellow beanie bites into a slice

Behind every order, a regular deciding where to go.

Who it’s for

Two sides of every order.

A regular smiling with a slice in a neighborhood pizzeria booth
Customer

The neighborhood regular

Orders from the same few local pizzerias a few times a month. Has tried chain loyalty apps and dropped them, the pattern behind the research above.

Main pain point“I never know when I’ve earned something, so I stop bothering.”
Needs A rule simple enough to repeat Progress they can see at a glance To know the moment they earn
An independent pizzeria owner behind his counter
Pizzeria owner

The independent shop owner

Runs a family pizzeria up against chain loyalty apps. Wants a program, but not the cost of pizzas earned elsewhere, or the time to run one.

Main pain pointChains win regulars with loyalty apps I can’t afford to build or fund.
Needs Zero setup, nothing to manage No cost for rewards earned elsewhere Regulars who come back to their shop
{{ ch.label }}

{{ ch.title }}

{{ ch.q }}

{{ b.cap }}
{{ b.cap }}
Brand cohesion

One brand, from the app to TV.

I worked with Creative and Marketing to align illustration, color and motion, so the campaign could use the product as-is. The TV spot was built on the screens I designed: order status, the Home tracker and the celebration.

The App Store listing leads with the same Home tracker, as “America’s biggest pizza rewards program.”

In the app: the You got a Pizza Point celebration
In the appThe celebration I designed.
On TV“It’s Called Slice Rewards”, built on the same screens.
{{ f.alt }}
{{ b.cap }}
{{ m.alt }}
{{ m.n }}{{ m.l }}
{{ b.cap }}
{{ m.alt }}{{ m.l }}
{{ b.cap }}
Model 01: Points + milestones
Model 01Points + milestonesPoints meant math. People had to work out what 125 was worth.
Model 02: Status tiers
Model 02Status tiersMost people order pizza a few times a month, so the first tier was months away. Too long to feel a reason to come back.
Model 03: Badges
Model 03BadgesBadges can support a program, but not be one. Kept as a later layer on top of the core rule.
Model 04: Points catalog
Model 04Points catalogA catalog meant pricing every reward, for 16,000 different menus.
Shipped: One rule: 8 orders = a free pie
ShippedOne rule: 8 orders = a free pieWhy it won: one rule anyone can repeat, at any pizzeria on Slice.
{{ b.cap }}
{{ b.alt }}
{{ b.cap }}
{{ b.cap }}
{{ b.alt }}
{{ b.cap }}

{{ b.t }}

  • {{ li.t }}
{{ b.c }}

{{ b.t }}

{{ it.alt }}
{{ it.n }}
{{ it.cap }}
{{ b.lab }}

{{ b.h }}

{{ pp.t }}

{{ b.lab }}

{{ b.h }}

{{ pp.t }}

My principle{{ b.pr }}

{{ b.el }}

{{ b.cap }}

{{ it.v }}{{ it.l }}
{{ it.n }}{{ it.h }}{{ it.t }}
{{ b.cap }}
{{ it.n }}{{ it.h }}{{ it.t }}
{{ b.h }}

{{ pp.t }}

{{ im.alt }}
{{ im.cap }}
{{ c.t }} {{ c.t }}
{{ p.cap }}
{{ ch.lapCap }}
{{ ch.baPhA }}
{{ ch.baA }}
{{ ch.baCapA }}
{{ ch.baPhB }}
{{ ch.baB }}
{{ ch.baCapB }}
{{ it.alt }}
{{ it.n }}
{{ it.cap }}
{{ ch.edgeT }}
{{ it.alt }}
{{ it.n }}
{{ it.cap }}
{{ ch.shotAlt }}
{{ ch.shotCap }}
{{ ch.bleedPh }}
{{ f.k }}{{ it.t }}{{ it.s }}
{{ ch.bleedCap }}
Result

{{ ch.result }}

“{{ ch.quote }}”

{{ ch.who }}
MVP · Iterations behind it Three surfaces, many rounds. I mapped every place Rewards could meet an order, then iterated each surface until it said one thing.

WhyConfusing rules were the top reason people quit chain programs, so every surface got one job and one message.

Explored: points bar at 1 of 8
01 · ExploredA points bar read as a meter, not pizza.
Explored: photo pie at 7 of 8
02 · ExploredA photo pie hid progress at small sizes.
Shipped: illustrated pie at 1 of 8
ShippedAn illustrated pie, legible from 1 to 8.
Flow: where Rewards meets Home, reorder, cart and menu
The map · Home, reorder, cart and menu entry points

01Home tracker

Wireframe, then a $25 photo pitch, then a points bar. The bar read as a progress meter, not pizza; the pie won.

Wire · 0/8 bar
Wire · 0/8 bar
Photo pitch · Join now
Photo pitch · Join now
Points bar · 1/8
Points bar · 1/8
Points bar · 8/8
Points bar · 8/8
Shipped · Pie 1/8
Shipped · Pie 1/8

02Rewards tab

A photo pie looked appetising but hid progress at small sizes. An illustrated pie kept it legible from 1 to 8.

Wire · 6/8
Wire · 6/8
Photo pie · 1/8
Photo pie · 1/8
Photo pie · 7/8
Photo pie · 7/8
Illustrated · 1/8
Illustrated · 1/8
Shipped · Your Rewards
Shipped · Your Rewards

03Cart

From an upsell (“spend $15”) to a plain confirmation that this order counts.

Wire · Make it count
Wire · Make it count
Qualifies · yellow card
Qualifies · yellow card
Reward available
Reward available
Shipped · Point confirmed
Shipped · Point confirmed
The Rewards tab

A home for the program, not a manual.

WhyPeople quit over rules they couldn’t follow, so the tab explains the program without adding rules.

Your Rewards leads with the pie and the one number that matters, then tip cards that slide: how to earn, what you get, what counts. How it works answers the questions from research in a collapsible FAQ, so the rule stays one line.

Tip cards slide with a spring and peek at the next one, so they read as swipeable. One FAQ open at a time; the chevron turns and the answer eases open. Try it: tap the tabs, the dots or a question.
Slice Rewards
7 more orders until a free large cheese pizza, pie tracker at 1 of 8
{{ rc.alt }}
Start your order
How it works: earn a Pizza Point per $15+ order, 8 points equal a free pizza, claim it in the Slice app
Frequently Asked Questions

{{ fq.a }}

View all Rewards FAQ
01 Designed02 Animated03 Shipped
Free pizza starts here!You just got your first Pizza Point. 8 Pizza Points = 1 free large cheese pizza.
Get your next Pizza PointLearn more about Slice Rewards
Welcome
Free pizza!To thank you for supporting small, family pizzerias, we’ll give you a free pizza once you’ve placed eight orders.
Tap anywhere to continue
Celebration
You got a Pizza Point!You just got your 6th Pizza Point. Once you have 8, you get a free large cheese pizza.
AwesomeLearn more about Slice Rewards
Earned
Congrats!You’ve earned your free large cheese pizza. Redeem it from any pizzeria.
Redeem nowRedeem later
Unlocked

Four moments, one message: you’re closer to a free pizza.

01 Designed02 Animated03 Shipped
{{ ch.mo.lab }}

{{ ch.mo.h }}

{{ pp.t }}

{{ ch.mo.el }}

{{ ch.mo.cap }}

01 Designed02 Animated03 Shipped
What shipped · three flows

One rule, met at three moments.

The same moments and motion, in the shipped flows. Each flow starts where people already were: web customers coming into the app, developing users mid-habit, and members cashing in.

{{ ch.flowSum }}

{{ fx.alt }}
{{ ch.fpFx }}
{{ ch.fpCount }}
Tap the screen to continue
Edge cases

Where trust breaks.

The three cases that mattered most: a pizza that costs more than the reward, a refund that takes a point back, and a reward about to expire.

Over the reward value: Up to $25 covered; the difference is shown before paying.
Over the reward valueUp to $25 covered; the difference is shown before paying.
Point removed: A cancelled, refunded order takes its point back, and says why.
Point removedA cancelled, refunded order takes its point back, and says why.
Expiry nudge: Seven days out, with the date and one button.
Expiry nudgeSeven days out, with the date and one button.
Go-to shops don’t deliver: The reward still works anywhere; browse nearby.
Go-to shops don’t deliverThe reward still works anywhere; browse nearby.
Pending point: Shown right away; the cart confirms it before checkout.
Pending pointShown right away; the cart confirms it before checkout.
Shop not in the program: Said up front, and again in the order summary.
Shop not in the programSaid up front, and again in the order summary.
Use it or save it: A toggle in checkout; the order still earns a point.
Use it or save itA toggle in checkout; the order still earns a point.
Delivery: Every nearby shop; open ones redeem, closed ones preorder.
DeliveryEvery nearby shop; open ones redeem, closed ones preorder.
Pickup: The same list, with ready times.
PickupThe same list, with ready times.
No shops nearby: A way out instead of a dead end.
No shops nearbyA way out instead of a dead end.
Craft · the Rewards system

A small kit that made it feel like pizza.

Eight tokens, one wordmark, three bursts and a pie with ten states. Every Rewards surface, from the Home module to Congrats, was built from these parts and specced for iOS and Android.

WhyThe pie had to read the same on a small Home module and a full-screen Congrats, so every surface was built from one kit.

Brand marks: Slice Rewards wordmark and three celebration bursts
The 8-slice pizza pie: ten states from 0/8 to reward ready
Rewards Home module anatomy and spec
Tokens: eight colours, Open Sans type scale, radius, spacing and motion rules
Celebration surfaces: red full-screen, white full-width, half-way drawer, Congrats
Slide cards: three swipeable education cards, auto-advance spec
FAQ accordion: collapsed and expanded states, motion spec
Shop cards and Redeem: open shops redeem, closed shops preorder
What I’d carry forward

Launch is the first experiment. Name the riskiest assumption, and instrument for it.

01
Delight is not decoration.I cut celebration as polish; it was how people learned the program.
02
Design the business model, too.Who pays for the reward shaped every message customers saw.
03
Make the model visible.Five options in the real Home screen got leadership to choose the simplest.